Cardiovascular effects of prolonged exercise

heart

It is well established that cardiovascular exercise is one of the best ways to improve heart health – but is it possible to do too much?

Well, in today’s article that is exactly what we aim to find out.

 

Does prolonged exercise cause heart disease?

A Group of runners running in a running race

It may go against conventional wisdom, but there are some people out there who seem to think that too much exercise can lead to heart disease – but is this true? 

Is too much exercise bad for your heart?

Or to be more specific, is too much cardio bad for your heart?

Well, in short, it can be.

Like anything in this world, when you take something to the extreme – even something as healthy as exercise – then there will be some negative consequences associated.

After all, more isn’t always better.

There is a growing body evidence clearly demonstrating that those individuals who take their exercise regime to the extreme may cause some nasty changes to their cardiovascular system – even potentially mitigating the health benefits initially associated with that exercise (Eijsvogels, 2018).

Some of these changes include:

  • Undesirable physical changes to the heart
  • Thickening of arterial walls
  • An increased risk of heart disease

Now, again it is important to note – this is certainly not the expectation with a healthy exercise regime, but rather what happens when aerobic exercise is taken to extreme levels.

 

How much is too much on your heart

We now know that excessive exercise can cause some rather negative changes to your heart – but can you damage your heart by exercising too hard?

As a general rule of thumb, we can break down exercisers into one of three categories, being light, moderate, and extreme:

  • Light exercises can be described as those who rarely break a sweat. Their exercise regimens typically consist of walking, gentle bike rides, or maybe a light jog. They only just meet the recommended guidelines of 150 minutes of aerobic activity per week, and it is mostly of very light intensity.
  • Moderate exercises are those who often exceed the recommended 150 minutes of aerobic activity per week. Using a combination of moderate-intensity exercise, with some vigorous-intensity exercise (think HIIT) thrown in for good measure. These guys are what we would consider being the fitter portion of the general population.
  • Then we have extreme exercisers. These are the 0.05% of the population that train for marathons, ultra-marathons, and iron man competitions. They put their body under extreme loads daily. Extreme exercisers, not only do they perform an exercise at a high intensity, but also a lot of it. 

With this in mind, how hard you exercise is not quite as important as how much

See, it is well established that a moderate amount of high intensity exercise each week is extremely good for your health – however, like anything, when taken to the extreme it becomes detrimental.

 

Atrial fibrillation and exercise

woman running on a treadmill

While ton the topic of extreme exercisers, I also wanted to touch on atrial fibrillation.

Atrial fibrillation is a common type of arrhythmia – which is the term used to describe an irregular heartbeat (Amin, 2016).

Under normal circumstances, your heart relies heavily on a consistent rhythm that comes from an electrical pattern within its own chambers. However, in with arterial fibrillation, this electrical pattern occurs irregularly – leading the upper chamber of the heart to quiver (or fibrillate).

Now, when it comes to exercise and Atrial fibrillation, things start to get a little interesting.

There is even some evidence showing that low-intensity aerobic exercise in sedentary people can improve upon the symptoms of Atrial fibrillation (Drca, 2014).

However, at the extreme end of this spectrum, we see a different story entirely.

In fact, high-level endurance athletes who participate in an extremely high volume of exercise are up to seven times more likely to develop Atrial fibrillation than someone from the general population (Molina, 2008).

As I alluded to above, high-level endurance athletes push their bodies to the limit every single day. Their cardiovascular system is under a degree of stress that most people will simply not experience in their lifetime.

And over time, this stress becomes damaging. 

I will say it again – too much of a good thing is rarely a good thing.

 

Ideal intensity and duration of exercise for heart health 

Now, enough about extreme exercise and the heart – instead, I want to outline some of the exercise recommendations for heart health.

Many people don’t realize it, but the World Health Organization have recently collated all the relevant research to develop some physical activity guidelines, To put it simply, if you manage to adhere to these guidelines on a weekly basis, then you can be sure your health is going to be optimal.

  • Adults aged 18–64 years should do at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic activity throughout the week, or at least 75 minutes of vigorous-intensity aerobic activity throughout the week (or a combination of the two).
  • Aerobic activity should be performed in bouts of at least 10 minutes duration.
  • For additional health benefits, adults should increase their moderate-intensity aerobic activity to 300 minutes per week, or 150 minutes of vigorous-intensity aerobic activity per week (or a combination of the two).

In practicality, this simply means performing some sort of exercise every single day, while making sure that some of it consists of vigorous-intensity exercise like high-intensity interval training.

You may like: Exercises For Improved Balance

 

Should athletes be worried?

There is obvious research to suggest that taking your exercise regime to extreme levels may have some detrimental effects on your cardiovascular system – however, it is important to place some caveats around this (Patil, 2012; O’Keefe, 2012).

Firstly, even among high-level athletes, this is a somewhat rare occurrence. This means that it won’t happen to everyone. It is more likely to happen in those who have a genetic predisposition to the issue occurring.

Secondly, there is a huge amount of research suggesting that high-level endurance athletes will still live longer than the general population. This is even despite these potential issues occurring. This means that the beneficial effects of exercise still appear to outweigh these negatives.

And finally, there is also some evidence demonstrating that some of the negative changes that occur in response to extreme exercise can revert back to normal after a period of lighter intensity exercise – so if you manage your training well, it may not pose a huge issue in the long term.

 

Other ways you can take care of your heart 

I wanted to finish this article by outlining some non-aerobic-exercise tips on how to keep your heart healthy. Each of these may seem a little obvious, but that does not make them any less important (or less effective):

  • Quit smoking
  • Eat more fiber (green leafy vegetables are king here)
  • Eat more fish
  • Incorporate nuts and seeds into your daily diet
  • Limit your intake of salt and saturated fat
  • Avoid processed meats, heavily processed carbohydrates, and junk food
  • Lift weights 2-3 times per week

If you can manage to tick all of these off while adhering to the exercise guidelines above, you can be sure your heart is going to be looking great.

 

Take-Home Message

Like anything else in this world, even exercise can become harmful if it is taken to the absolute extreme.

However, it is important to note that the negative effects of extreme exercise pose less risk than not exercising at all. Moreover, they do appear to be mitigated if you make sure that you monitor your exercise loads and stay out of extreme ranges.

So if you exercise smart, you have nothing to worry about.

 

References

Eijsvogels, Thijs MH, Paul D. Thompson, and Barry A. Franklin. “The “extreme exercise hypothesis”: recent findings and cardiovascular health implications.” Current treatment options in cardiovascular medicine 20.10 (2018): 84.

Amin, Anish, et al. “The current approach of atrial fibrillation management.” Avicenna journal of medicine 6.1 (2016): 8.

Drca, Nikola, et al. “Atrial fibrillation is associated with different levels of physical activity levels at different ages in men.” Heart 100.13 (2014): 1037-1042.

Molina, Lluis, et al. “Long-term endurance sport practice increases the incidence of lone atrial fibrillation in men: a follow-up study.” Europace 10.5 (2008): 618-623.

Patil, Harshal R., et al. “Cardiovascular damage resulting from chronic excessive endurance exercise.” Missouri medicine 109.4 (2012): 312.

O’Keefe, James H., et al. “Potential adverse cardiovascular effects from excessive endurance exercise.” Mayo Clinic Proceedings. Vol. 87. No. 6. Elsevier, 2012.

You May Like!

woman drinking water

Water and Hydration

Hunter Bennett Given that your body is approximately 60 percent water, it stands to reason...
woman holding a pillow over her head

Menopause and Sleep

Hunter Bennett Menopause is commonly considered to be one of the most trying times in...
Girl riding bike wearing virtual reality goggles

Virtual Reality Exercise

Jessica Gillespie-Friesen What if the secret to boosting your performance at the gym was simply...
To women jumping on boxes

The Rise of CrossFit

Hunter Bennett Over the last few years, we have seen a resurgence in both high-intensity...
Man holding his knee that has a brace on it.

4 Signs of Arthritis

Ryan Cross, Physiotherapist Most people know someone affected by arthritis or have symptoms of arthritis...
Man jumping

Muscle Growth and Loss

Dayton Kelly Muscle growth may not be entirely lost following detraining: a paradigm shift in...
FODMAP and exercise

FODMAPS and Exercise

Dayton Kelly FODMAPs: A culprit in exercise-induced gastrointestinal distress and an explanation for athlete adoption...
Exercising in the Heat

Exercising in the Heat

Alyssa Bialowas As temperatures continue to soar in the summer, it’s important to be cognizant...
3 benefits of CrossFit

3 Benefits of CrossFit

Alyssa Biawolas CrossFit remains to be one of the most popular and most controversial fitness...
best sleep aids

Best Sleep Aids

Getting a good night’s sleep isn’t just nice. It’s essential. As The National Heart, Lung,...
Best Sleep Trackers

6 Best Sleep Trackers

Have you ever felt like you aren’t getting the recommended eight to nine hours of rest...
5 Best Sleep Apps

5 Best Sleep Apps

Are you trying to track your sleep so you can get a better night’s rest?...
woman sprinting on a track

The Biomechanics of Sprinting

Alyssa Biawolas Understanding the biomechanics of sprint running form is essential to successful sprint performance....
pacer

Do You Need A Pacer?

Alyssa Bialowas Introduction Strong displays in endurance sport are as much about pacing as training....
practicing meditation

Go Forth & Be Mindful

Hank Shell Well, folks, 2017 is drawing to a close, there’s still no natural snow...

Don’t Skip Ankle Mobility

Ankle mobility affects the entire kinetic train. Low back pain? Plantar fasciitis? Tight Hamstrings? Ankle...

How HIIT Changes Our Body

Evan Stevens Researchers looked at how HIIT (high intensity interval training) changed glucose metabolism in...
hockey players

HIIT For Hockey Performance

Ryan Cross, B.A. Hons (Kin), MScPT, FCAMPT Registered Physiotherapist in Sarnia, Ontario, Canada The hockey...

The Will To Compete

Mike Choi, 45, is a competitive masters weightlifter. Mike was a “weekend warrior” until he...

Strengthen Your Rotator Cuff

Forever Fit Science physical therapist, Ryan Cross, demonstrates a simple rotator cuff exercise. By performing...

4 Essential Exercises

Dayton Kelly Essential to the development of any strong training plan is the concept of...
woman runner with headache

Headaches and VO2 max

Catherine O’Brien Headaches are a prominent health concern with 1 out of every 7 Americans...
omega 3 foods

Fill Up On Omega-3s

Dayton Kelly This article was adapted from a combination of speeches given at the European...
fit 55

Crossfit For All Ages

Katie Rose Hejtmanek, PhD Stay Strong, Mobile, and Able! “It is a great feeling when...
happy walker

Run/Walk Or Run Only?

Catherine O’Brien When I first started running, my mom introduced me to the Galloway Method....

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Guide

Ryan Cross – B.A. Hons (Kin), MScPT, FCAMPT Registered Physiotherapist at CBI Physiotherapy and Rehabilitation...

Post-Concussion Management

Catherine O’Brien Post-Concussion Syndrome and Treatment In this article on the topic of concussion, I...
ankle bone

Ankle Sprains Start In The Hip

Ryan Cross – B.A. Hons (Kin), MScPT, FCAMPT Registered Physiotherapist at CBI Physiotherapy and Rehabilitation Centre...

5 Bio-Motor Abilities

Forever Fit Science’s founder Virginia Davies explains the 5 bio-motor abilities crucial to a well-rounded...

Training Program For Autism

Catherine O’Brien Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is a developmental disorder associated with impaired social ability,...

It’s All In The Hips

Ryan Cross – B.A. Hons (Kin), MScPT, FCAMPT Registered Physiotherapist at CBI Physiotherapy and Rehabilitation Centre...

Fit and Happy

Catherine O’Brien Fit and Happy Growing up, my mother always encouraged me and my three...

Exercise And PMS

Catherine O’Brien Exercise and PMS: A case for exercising during menstruation To exercise or to...

What Is Your Why?

Forever Fit Science Master Athletes tell their why for competing and staying active.  From not...

Mental Game Tip

The Game Forever Fit Science Master Racquetball Athlete and veteran of the U.S. Air Force...
Getting There

Getting There

Paul Stevens Carpe Diem (but in a relaxed sort of way) “GETTING THERE” Today was...

Crunch Time!

Paul Stevens Carpe Diem (but in a relaxed sort of way) “CRUNCH TIME!!!” I’m a...