Children & Relative Age Effect

girl rock climbing

Alyssa Bialowas

Relative Age Effect is the bias that athletes at the top level of their sport are older, and were born in months earlier in their sports relative cut-off period. For instance, a hockey player born in January of the same year as a hockey player born in December is almost a whole year older, and arguably more biologically, physically and emotionally mature. Research has widely concluded that athletes born earlier have a higher chance of success when it comes to sport, as they will be competing against others who are much younger but born in the same year.

Older athletes tend to be over-represented in sports where there is a talent selection process, which means the system lacks fairness and an overall acknowledgment that younger children are often less biologically mature and should be given an equal chance.

 

Study

family runningTo examine Relative Age Effect in children, Müller, Hildebrandt and Raschner (2017) studied young athletes at the 7th International Children’s Winter Games in 2016. The study looked at 572 participants (365 males and 207 females) from 22 different countries ranging from 12.1 to 15.0 years. Three birth years (2001 to 2003) and birth months were used to establish twelve groups of relative age quartiles, and the participants were divided into three maturity groups: late, normal and early maturing.

Related Article: FUNtervals – Exercise Intervals For Children

The different sports were also divided into three types – strength-, endurance-, and technique-related sports. Alpine skiing and hockey were categorized as strength-related; biathlon, cross-country skiing and speed skating were categorized as endurance-related; and figure skating, snowboarding and freestyle skiing were categorized as technique-related.

 

Results

Strength- and endurance-related sports were based on the power and endurance of the participant, and technique-related sports were determined by judging points. There was an over-representation of athletes born at the beginning of the first eligible age group and an under-representation of athletes born in the last relative age quarters.

Related Article: Study Shows Active Children Are Better At Math

The likelihood of selection for the International Children’s Winter Games was 3.5 times higher for an older athlete than from the last relative age quarter. For male athletes, the likelihood was 3.1 times higher, and for female athletes, the likelihood was 4.2 times higher. The results of the study revealed that the majority of younger athletes only had a chance for selection if they were early maturing, while older athletes had an increased likelihood of selection regardless of their biological maturity.

 

Takeaway

Further research would benefit by looking at a wider range of sports, especially group sports where individuals are explicitly up against each other. It would also be beneficial to be more specific in terms of types of sports, for instance including individual strength-related sports vs. group strength-related sports, etc. The winter sport selection process should not discriminate against younger athletes and needs to incorporate fairer selectiveness by considering relative age and biological maturity status.

You Might Like:

Kettlebell exercises

The 2020 Kettlebell Shortage Explained

I don’t know about you, but since this whole COVID-19 situation entered full swing, I have been trying desperately to get my hands on some gym equipment I can use at home. In fact, what...
Woman exercising with her dog

How to Get Back Into Exercise After Time Off

With COVID-19 restrictions slowly starting to ease, you are probably itching to get back into exercise – I mean, I know I am. However, I am here to tell you that you should probably take...
Woman stretching

How to Set Health Goals After COVID-19

We are almost there. By all accounts, things are finally on the up, and we should be able to get back into our normal routine over the coming months. Which means that you have a...
Intermittent Fasting and running

Ketogenic Diet and Running: What You Need to Know

If you have been around the health and fitness space over the last few years, then you would have heard about the ketogenic diet. You know that diet that helps with weight loss, metabolic disease,...
Woman running

Intermittent Fasting and Running

Intermittent fasting has quickly become one of the most popular dietary strategies of the decade. Over the last few years, it has evolved from a niche topic into something that everyone is doing. And with...

References:

Müller, L., Hildebrandt, C., and Raschner, L. (2017). The Role of a Relative Age Effect in the 7 International Children’s Winter Games 2016 and the Influence of Biological Maturity on Selection. Journal of Sports Science and Medicine, 16: 195-202.

Reset your health

Now Is the Time to Reset Your Health

Women playing soccer

Exercise Research is Underrepresented in Female Athletes

salt

Does a high salt diet cause cognitive impairment?

Metabolic

Metabolic Flexibility: The Key to Unlocking your Health

Sweat

What Your Sweat Says About Your Fitness Health

Meat

The Truth About Red Meat Consumption

woman running on a treadmill

Exercise: Is It Passion Or Addiction?

woman standing on a beach flexing both her arms

Prolonged Fasting for Health & Longevity

ab roller

How Core Strength Effects Athletic Performance

football

Should I Let My Child Play Football?

Leave a Reply